Every closing moves money, and every party to it has an email inbox. That combination is why real estate remains a steady target for fraud. The good news is that most of it is preventable with a few habits that every buyer, seller, attorney, broker and lender can follow.
What the numbers show
The FBI’s 2025 Internet Crime Report counted 12,368 real estate fraud complaints and $275.1 million in reported losses, up from about $173 million in 2024, as the American Land Title Association reported in April. Later that month, ALTA highlighted a report finding that one in five homebuyers received suspicious or fraudulent communication during closing.
Those are the cases that were reported. They show the risk is real for every transaction, not only large ones.
How it usually happens
In the typical scheme, someone impersonates a party to the closing, often the title company, an attorney or an agent, and sends new wiring instructions that look legitimate. The message often arrives near the closing date and asks for speed. Old Republic Title advises carefully evaluating any request for secrecy or pressure to act quickly.
The verification steps
- Call, don’t email. Confirm all wiring instructions by phone before transferring funds.
- Use a number you already have. Call the title company at a trusted number it gave you earlier, never a number from the email asking for the wire.
- Be suspicious of changes. It is not common for title companies to change wiring instructions and payment information.
- Confirm the account name, not only the number. Ask your bank to confirm the name on the receiving account before sending.
- Forward, don’t reply. When responding to an email about funds, forward it and type the address yourself, so a lookalike address can’t slip through.
- Confirm receipt. Call the title company to confirm the funds arrived.
If funds may have gone to the wrong account
Time matters. Old Republic Title notes that detecting a misdirected wire within 24 hours gives the best chance of recovering the money. Notify your bank and the title or escrow agent on the file immediately, contact local law enforcement, and file a complaint with the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center at ic3.gov.
Questions before you send funds
If anything about wiring instructions on a United American Title Agency file looks unusual, call our office at the number listed on uatitleagency.com before sending any funds. A short call is always worth it.
Fraud prevention works when every party follows the same habits. If you are an attorney, broker or lender working with us, we are glad to walk your clients through these steps before closing day.
Explore our services for attorneys, order title, or contact United American Title Agency at (718) 441-2027.
Sources: American Land Title Association, press release on the FBI 2025 Internet Crime Report, April 10, 2026; ALTA, “Report: 1 in 5 Homebuyers Receive Suspicious or Fraudulent Communication During Closing,” April 28, 2026; Old Republic Title, “Beware of Wire Fraud” (OR1742, 06/2026).